Home › Food and Drink › Ice cream shop
The 10 Best Ice Cream Shops in Baltimore (2026)
Baltimore has a lively scene for frozen treats, from classic ice cream counters to dessert-focused shops. This list is built from Google review data and updated for 2026 using a Bayesian-style score that weights average ratings by review count to balance quality and popularity. We focused on businesses categorized on Google as Ice Cream or Dessert shop and ranked them strictly by that computed score. Whether you’re a visitor or a local looking for a reliable scoop, these are the highest-rated options across the city according to public reviews.
This ranking is computed from Google reviews (our method). Listings marked Partner are paid advertising spots: they sit alongside the ranking without changing its order.
Are you a ice cream shop in Baltimore?
People reading this page are looking for a pro right now. Put your business above the ranking, with your contact details and a link to your site.
✓ Live immediately · ✓ One-time payment · ✓ No subscription
10 of 10 spots still available
Cajou Plant-Based Ice Cream
Cajou Plant-Based Ice Cream tops our list with a perfect 5.0 Google rating backed by 681 reviews, and it’s listed under Ice Cream. The plant-based descriptor in the name is reflected in its listing, and the large number of reviews gives the score significant weight in our Bayesian-style ranking. That combination of a flawless rating and substantial review volume is what pushes it to number one in 2026.
The full ranking
Kwality Ice Cream & Juice Corner
Kwality Ice Cream & Juice Corner is rated 4.9 on Google with 715 reviews and appears under Ice Cream. It is located on Baltimore National Pike in Catonsville, giving it a strong review base outside central Baltimore.
715 reviews
Moo Moo Cows – Ice Cream
Moo Moo Cows – Ice Cream carries a 4.9 Google rating from 684 reviews and is listed as Ice Cream. The shop’s address on Light Street places it in Baltimore and contributes a substantial number of reviews.
684 reviews
Hershey’s Ice Cream
Hershey’s Ice Cream shows a 4.9 rating with 377 Google reviews and is categorized as Ice Cream. It is located on S Broadway in Baltimore.
377 reviews
Sydney’s Ice Creams
Sydney’s Ice Creams has a 4.9 Google rating based on 132 reviews and is listed as Ice Cream. The address on Harford Road places it in Baltimore’s northeast area.
132 reviews
Hersheys’s Ice Cream (Light Street)
Hersheys’s Ice Cream (Light Street) posts a 4.9 rating across 112 Google reviews and is categorized as Ice Cream. Its listing on Light Street identifies it as a Baltimore location.
112 reviews
Ice Queens Snowball Shop
Ice Queens Snowball Shop holds a 4.8 Google rating from 632 reviews and is classified as a Dessert shop. The business is located on E Fort Avenue in Baltimore.
632 reviews
CRAVE Baltimore City
CRAVE Baltimore City has a 4.8 rating with 331 Google reviews and appears in the Dessert shop category. It operates on S High Street in Baltimore.
331 reviews
Tia’s Italian ice
Tia’s Italian ice is rated 4.8 on Google from 244 reviews and is listed as Ice Cream. The shop’s address on W 36th Street situates it in Baltimore.
244 reviews
Noel’s Italian Ice and Ice Cream
Noel’s Italian Ice and Ice Cream shows a 5.0 Google rating, though it has 13 reviews and is classified as Ice Cream. Its listed location is on E Monument Street in Baltimore.
13 reviews
Frequently asked questions
How should I choose the right ice cream shop in Baltimore?
Look at recent Google ratings and the number of reviews to gauge consistency; a high rating with many reviews generally indicates broader consensus. Also check the shop’s menu or category for the types you want (e.g., traditional ice cream, Italian ice, or plant-based options), plus hours and location for convenience.
What can I expect to pay at a typical ice cream shop?
Prices vary by portion size, specialty flavors, and add-ons, so expect variability from place to place. Check the shop’s website or call ahead for menu and pricing details to avoid surprises.
What should I check before ordering ice cream for an event?
Confirm availability for the date and time, ask about minimum order sizes or lead time, and verify delivery or setup options if needed. Also discuss flavor options, dietary accommodations (like dairy-free or nut-free), and any cancellation or refund policies.
How was this ranking created?
The list is built from Google review data and updated for 2026 using a Bayesian-style approach that weights average ratings by the number of reviews. That method helps balance high scores from few reviews against strong performance backed by many customer opinions.