Home › Food and Drink › Pizza place
The 10 Best Pizza Places in Baltimore (2026)
Baltimore’s pizza scene is varied and neighborhood-driven, from grab-and-go slices to full-service pizzerias. This list was assembled using Google review data and a Bayesian-style score (the average rating weighted by review count) to balance high ratings with review volume. It was updated for 2026 to reflect current public feedback across the city. Use these rankings as a starting point when deciding where to eat or order: they emphasize both consistent high ratings and the number of people who’ve left reviews, giving a practical view of popular options in Baltimore.
This ranking is computed from Google reviews (our method). Listings marked Partner are paid advertising spots: they sit alongside the ranking without changing its order.
Are you a pizza place in Baltimore?
People reading this page are looking for a pro right now. Put your business above the ranking, with your contact details and a link to your site.
✓ Live immediately · ✓ One-time payment · ✓ No subscription
10 of 10 spots still available
Angeli’s Pizzeria & Bar
Our top pick is Angeli’s Pizzeria & Bar at 1035 S Charles St, which posts a standout 4.9 rating supported by 947 Google reviews. That combination of an exceptional score and substantial review volume pushes it to the top under our weighting method. Listed on Google as a Pizza business, its rating reliability comes from both quality and quantity of feedback. For readers, that means this location consistently attracts a large number of reviewers while maintaining near-perfect scores.
The full ranking
Little Donna’s
Little Donna’s shows a 4.9 Google rating with 378 reviews and appears under the Restaurant category at 1812 Bank St, reflecting a strong local following.
378 reviews
TinyBrickOven
With a 4.8 rating across 1,378 Google reviews, TinyBrickOven is listed as Pizza and is located at 1036 Light St, demonstrating broad reviewer engagement.
1378 reviews
Benny’s (Formerly Joe Benny’s)
Benny’s (Formerly Joe Benny’s) carries a 4.8 Google score from 944 reviews, is categorized as Italian, and can be found at 300 S High St.
944 reviews
Kechy Pizza Co
Kechy Pizza Co is recorded at 4.8 on Google with 697 reviews and is listed in the Restaurant category at 207 E Redwood St.
697 reviews
Barfly’s
Barfly’s holds a 4.8 rating from 528 Google reviews, categorized as Pizza and located at 620 E Fort Ave.
528 reviews
Angeli’s Pizzeria &Bar
This entry, Angeli’s Pizzeria &Bar (note the listing punctuation), is shown as Pizza with a 4.8 rating based on 290 reviews and sits at 1203 W Mt Royal Ave.
290 reviews
Pizza Harbor
Pizza Harbor appears in Google as Pizza with a 4.8 rating from 106 reviews and is listed at 2 E Wells St.
106 reviews
Angeli’s Pizzeria & Bar
A separate Angeli’s Pizzeria & Bar listing shows a larger footprint with a 4.7 rating across 2,430 Google reviews and the address 413 S High St; it remains one of the most-reviewed pizza entries.
2430 reviews
Pie in the Sky
Pie in the Sky posts a 4.7 Google rating backed by 2,284 reviews, categorized as Pizza and located at 716 S Broadway.
2284 reviews
Frequently asked questions
How is this ranking built?
This list is derived from Google review data using a Bayesian-style approach: the average rating is weighted by the number of reviews to balance highly rated but sparsely reviewed spots against popular places with many opinions. It was updated for 2026 to reflect current Google listings and review counts.
What should I consider when choosing a pizza place in Baltimore?
Look at both the average rating and the number of reviews to judge consistency; read recent reviews for service and timing notes. Also check whether the place offers dine-in, takeout, delivery, or special hours that match your needs.
How much does pizza typically cost?
Prices vary by size, toppings, and whether you order a whole pie or single slices, and they differ between quick-slice counters and sit-down pizzerias. For reliable pricing, consult the restaurant’s menu online or call ahead before placing a larger order.
When should I call a place instead of just walking in?
Call ahead for large orders, group reservations, or when you need a specific pickup time—weekends and event nights can be especially busy. Also call if you have dietary questions or need to confirm hours, since online information can sometimes be out of date.