Home › Business Services › Insurance broker

Insurance broker in Baltimore

The 10 Best Insurance Brokers in Baltimore (2026)

Picking the right insurance broker in Baltimore often starts online. This ranking uses a Bayesian score — the Google average rating weighted by number of reviews — to order the top local agencies and agents, and it was updated for 2026. We prioritized establishments that appear consistently in Google search and have meaningful review volume so you can compare well-reviewed, active options around the city. Use this list as a practical starting point: call to confirm services, request quotes, and read policy details before you sign. Baltimore’s varied neighborhoods mean needs differ — compare quotes for your situation.

22 analyzed10 shortlisted4.9/5 average rating4,653 Google reviews

This ranking is computed from Google reviews (our method). Listings marked Partner are paid advertising spots: they sit alongside the ranking without changing its order.

Are you a insurance broker in Baltimore?

People reading this page are looking for a pro right now. Put your business above the ranking, with your contact details and a link to your site.

✓ Live immediately  ·  ✓ One-time payment  ·  ✓ No subscription

10 of 10 spots still available

Our pick 2026

Wayne Nieberlein – GEICO Insurance Agent

5/5 · 1905 Google reviews · 6241 Falls Rd Ste 101, Baltimore, MD 21209

Wayne Nieberlein – GEICO Insurance Agent comes out on top because it pairs a perfect 5.0 Google rating with very large review volume — 1,905 reviews — which the Bayesian method rewards. Listed on Google as an Insurance agency, that combination of top score and high count gives it a strong statistical advantage in our ranking. For anyone prioritizing broad online validation, this entry leads the list.

The full ranking

2

Liz Sherstad – State Farm Insurance Agent

1414 Key Hwy Ste P300M, Baltimore, MD 21230 · website

With a perfect 5.0 and 554 reviews, Liz Sherstad – State Farm Insurance Agent appears on Google as an Insurance agency.

5/5
554 reviews
3

Baltimore Equitable Insurance

509 S Exeter St Ste 420, Baltimore, MD 21202 · website

Baltimore Equitable Insurance is listed as an Insurance company on Google with a 5.0 rating based on 93 reviews.

5/5
93 reviews
4

Main Line Benefits – Adam Richter

1936 Eastern Ave, Baltimore, MD 21231 · website

Carrying a 4.9 average from 691 reviews, Main Line Benefits – Adam Richter is categorized on Google as a Health insurance agency.

4.9/5
691 reviews
5

Baltimore Insurance Network

1414 Key Hwy Ste E, Baltimore, MD 21230 · website

Baltimore Insurance Network earns a 4.9 score from 516 reviewers and is shown as an Insurance agency in Google listings.

4.9/5
516 reviews
6

Carlos Sanchez: Allstate Insurance

1609 Eastern Ave, Baltimore, MD 21231 · website

Carlos Sanchez: Allstate Insurance records a 4.9 rating across 440 Google reviews and is listed under Insurance agency.

4.9/5
440 reviews
7

Kirby Insurance Agency

5517 Oregon Ave, Halethorpe, MD 21227 · website

Located in Halethorpe, Kirby Insurance Agency holds a 4.9 rating with 210 Google reviews and is categorized as an Insurance agency.

4.9/5
210 reviews
8

Wolf Insurance Agency

9124 Belair Rd, Baltimore, MD 21236

Wolf Insurance Agency has a 4.9 average from 121 reviews and appears on Google as an Insurance agency.

4.9/5
121 reviews
9

Mason & Carter Inc

233 E Redwood St Ste 1100A, Baltimore, MD 21202 · website

Mason & Carter Inc shows a 4.9 rating with 92 Google reviews and is listed as an Insurance agency.

4.9/5
92 reviews
10

Great Oak Insurance Group

1340 Smith Ave #200, Baltimore, MD 21209 · website

Great Oak Insurance Group posts a perfect 5.0 rating from 31 Google reviews and is categorized as an Insurance agency.

5/5
31 reviews
Ranking built with our weighted score (Google rating × how reliable the review count is) across 22 businesses analyzed in Baltimore — our methodology.

Frequently asked questions

How should I choose an insurance broker in Baltimore?

Start by matching the broker’s experience to your needs—auto, home, health, or commercial coverage—and look for clear communication. Compare multiple quotes, read recent online reviews, and ask about license status and whether they represent specific carriers or work independently.

How much does it cost to work with an insurance broker?

Many brokers are paid by insurance carriers through commissions and may not charge clients a separate fee, but practices vary. Ask up front about any fees or commission arrangements, and compare total premium costs across brokers and direct insurers before deciding.

What should I check before hiring a broker?

Verify that the broker is licensed in Maryland and ask for references or recent client examples if available. Also review policy terms, exclusions, and how the broker handles claims advocacy so you understand the level of service you’ll receive.

How was this ranking compiled and updated?

This list was built from Google review data and ordered using a Bayesian-style score that weights average ratings by review volume; the goal is to balance high scores with meaningful numbers of reviews. Entries and positions were updated for 2026 to reflect current Google ratings and counts.

Scroll to Top